I wish I knew more about plotting a novel. It’s one of the reasons I kick myself for not beginning my writing career earlier in life. If I’d spent my twenties starving in a garret as a writer, I’d be through the worst of the learning curve now. I’d have finished the 10,000 hours of practice that Malcolm Gladwell argues is needed to develop mastery of a subject. See Outliers: The Story of Success (2008).
I’ve approached plotting differently with each of the three novels I have drafted. On my first novel, I just started writing. I didn’t know any better. I got to the end, then went back and edited. And edited. And edited. I’m still editing it.
On the second, I knew the beginning and the end, and had a very detailed plan for how to get there, but I still had to stop frequently to do detailed research to be sure I was historically accurate. I finished the first draft, then went back and edited. I’m still editing it, too.
On the third novel – also historical fiction – I was somewhere in between in my planning. More stops for research. I’ve only just completed the first draft of this book. It’s the shortest novel I’ve written, and the next draft needs substantial expansion. So I’ll be editing it for awhile, too.
None of my plotting approaches has worked well, and all required – and will require – several re-writes to get something approximating a compelling plot. I know re-writing is as important as writing, but I’m lazy and impatient, so I’d like to figure out how to minimize the re-writing.
A couple of years ago, I participated in a writing seminar that offered a really simple approach to plotting that I might try. Claudia Suzanne gave a session at the Muse Online Writing Conference in 2010 called “Plot Your Novel in 15 Minutes or Less!” Her advice: “decide where the story begins and ends, and let imagination and logic fill in the gaps.”
It works like this:
- List the numbers 1-15 down the side of your page
- On Line 1, give a one sentence description of how the novel begins.
- On Line 15, give a one sentence description of how the novel ends.
- Then go to Line 2, and describe what happens next after the beginning.
- Then go to Line 14, and describe what happens just before the end.
- Go back and forth from beginning to end until all 15 lines are filled in.
Now you should have a rough plot.
Once you’re done with the 15 points, you can flesh it out with your characters, subplots, etc. Ms. Suzanne says screenwriters have been plotting this way for years. For more information, you can go to her website at http://claudiasuzanne.com/. She does speaking engagements on this topic, if your writing group is interested. See also http://wambtac.com.
For those of you planning to participate in NaNoWriMo (a/k/a National Novel Writing Month . . . better known as November to the non-writers among us), maybe you can try this technique to outline your book. Success in NaNoWriMo is a 50,000 word novel written entirely during the month of November. To get your 50,000 words, you just need 3,334 words on each of the 15 points in your outline! You can do your plotting in October, but don’t start writing until November.
I won’t be joining you this month during NaNoWriMo. With any luck, I’ll be editing the novels I’ve already written. Maybe I’ll even finish one.
Sounds like a good idea. I guess I’m more of a linear thinker. I do the beginning and the end then go back to point #2 and work down.
Whatever works!
I’m thinking of taking part in NaNoWriMo this year, but still a little undecided.
Good luck . . . even if you don’t complete the draft in a month, you’ll have made a good start.
For me, NaNoWriMo is a “bucket list” item.
Theresa
Nice information, thank you. It’s basically how I teach outlining for speech or writing classes but hadn’t thought that way for a book. Just brainstorm. Nothing is written in stone and you can change it a lot easier w/15 points than you can with 300 pages. Same is true for public speaking. If the idea is brainstormed and outlined, you can play with details more freely. Interesting.
And yet, 15 points is much easier to follow than a blank sheet of paper! There must be a happy medium somewhere.
For those of you who want to know more about novel structure, see Kristen Lamb’s current series on her blog. Kristen is the author of We Are Not Alone: The Writer’s Guide to Social Media.
The first part of her series is at http://warriorwriters.wordpress.com/2012/09/24/anatomy-of-a-best-selling-novel-structure-part-one/
Once you have your 15 brainstorming steps, then rethink them per the structure of a novel that Kristen describes.
Theresa
I like to tie the ending to my opening, guess this is called roundabout or some such thing. Glad I write non-fiction, I am not a ‘what if’ writer. Very interesting though and could apply.
Reblogged this on Write Brain Trust and commented:
Here’s a post from my blog Story & History on plotting a novel. Hope it works for friends of WriteBrainTrust who are participating in NaNoWriMo.
Theresa Hupp
[…] easy plotting method if you have no idea how to […]
[…] night, I tried this exercise I read in Theresa Hupp’s blog post. The exercise is an attempt to “decide where the story begins and ends, and let imagination and […]
[…] he says he got this outlining idea from Teresa Hupp. I’m betting she lifted it from somewhere else. It’s one of those things that flies […]
[…] actually get to the heart of the book. Yesterday I filled out a 12-point quick outline in the style Theresa Hupp mentioned on her blog. Couldn’t remember how many points it was supposed to have when I worked on it, but it really […]
[…] about writing. See my posts about keeping a journal, about writing memoir and family myths, about plotting a novel, and about critique […]
Great post Theresa. I should have thought of this, a little from the start, a little from the finish and work your way into the middle. It is how I manage so many things in my life, including burning the candle at both ends. 🙂
Thanks for the comment. I need to finish my current WIPs so I can start fresh and try this myself!
Theresa
Sounds like a good idea. I guess I’m more of a linear thinker. I do the beginning and the end then go back to point #2 and work down.
Whatever works!
I’m thinking of taking part in NaNoWriMo this year, but still a little undecided.
Good luck . . . even if you don’t complete the draft in a month, you’ll have made a good start.
For me, NaNoWriMo is a “bucket list” item.
Theresa
Nice information, thank you. It’s basically how I teach outlining for speech or writing classes but hadn’t thought that way for a book. Just brainstorm. Nothing is written in stone and you can change it a lot easier w/15 points than you can with 300 pages. Same is true for public speaking. If the idea is brainstormed and outlined, you can play with details more freely. Interesting.
And yet, 15 points is much easier to follow than a blank sheet of paper! There must be a happy medium somewhere.
For those of you who want to know more about novel structure, see Kristen Lamb’s current series on her blog. Kristen is the author of We Are Not Alone: The Writer’s Guide to Social Media.
The first part of her series is at http://warriorwriters.wordpress.com/2012/09/24/anatomy-of-a-best-selling-novel-structure-part-one/
Once you have your 15 brainstorming steps, then rethink them per the structure of a novel that Kristen describes.
Theresa
I like to tie the ending to my opening, guess this is called roundabout or some such thing. Glad I write non-fiction, I am not a ‘what if’ writer. Very interesting though and could apply.
Reblogged this on Write Brain Trust and commented:
Here’s a post from my blog Story & History on plotting a novel. Hope it works for friends of WriteBrainTrust who are participating in NaNoWriMo.
Theresa Hupp
[…] easy plotting method if you have no idea how to […]
[…] night, I tried this exercise I read in Theresa Hupp’s blog post. The exercise is an attempt to “decide where the story begins and ends, and let imagination and […]
[…] he says he got this outlining idea from Teresa Hupp. I’m betting she lifted it from somewhere else. It’s one of those things that flies […]
[…] actually get to the heart of the book. Yesterday I filled out a 12-point quick outline in the style Theresa Hupp mentioned on her blog. Couldn’t remember how many points it was supposed to have when I worked on it, but it really […]
[…] about writing. See my posts about keeping a journal, about writing memoir and family myths, about plotting a novel, and about critique […]
Great post Theresa. I should have thought of this, a little from the start, a little from the finish and work your way into the middle. It is how I manage so many things in my life, including burning the candle at both ends. 🙂
Thanks for the comment. I need to finish my current WIPs so I can start fresh and try this myself!
Theresa